Jump to content

SD70MACH - Delivery and Updates


jackathan

Recommended Posts

Metra has been delivering the locomotives that will be used in future service: https://metra.com/newsroom/new-metra-locomotive-debuts

According to the Trains article (https://www.trains.com/trn/news-reviews/news-wire/news-photo-another-metra-sd70mach-delivered/), the fourth unit of the SD70MACH, METX #505, has been delivered on May 11, 2023.

METX #500 is going to be a heritage livery, in commemoration of the upcoming RTA's 50th anniversary.

Let's get this discussion rolling!

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 4 months later...
  • 2 weeks later...
  • 2 months later...

Metra needs a new revenue line.  The rebuilts SD70s would look cool on excursion trains to Ill Rail museum.   They have the Rockford project it os possible.   Metra can get into running more excursion trains. They have experience with steam trains, take over Polar express operationa from Amtrak, bring back the bar cars/parlor cars, use off peak parties to downtown, bacholor parties, wedings, etc.  Why have pub crawls when you can have it on the train

Link to comment
Share on other sites

12 hours ago, Railguy said:

Metra needs a new revenue line.  The rebuilts SD70s would look cool on excursion trains to Ill Rail museum.   They have the Rockford project it os possible.   Metra can get into running more excursion trains. They have experience with steam trains, take over Polar express operationa from Amtrak, bring back the bar cars/parlor cars, use off peak parties to downtown, bacholor parties, wedings, etc.  Why have pub crawls when you can have it on the train

Only tangentially related to this topic, and not only is Metra not in that business, I doubt that it would be allowed to enter that line of business.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

15 hours ago, Railguy said:

Metra needs a new revenue line.  The rebuilts SD70s would look cool on excursion trains to Ill Rail museum.   They have the Rockford project it os possible.   Metra can get into running more excursion trains. They have experience with steam trains, take over Polar express operations from Amtrak, bring back the bar cars/parlor cars, use off peak parties to downtown, bachelor parties, weddings, etc.  Why have pub crawls when you can have it on the train

I would love to see Metra running trains directly to the Rail Museum on weekends.

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

27 minutes ago, Railguy said:

My point was jest as to putting  these SD70s to some use

Their use is to haul commuter cars. YouTubers have video of them on the MD-N and MD-W.

You think Metra bought 15 locos just to mothball them?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not intentionally.  Metra bought the wrong type of equipment for regional service including old frieght engines and the new cars on order.  Sure they ran in service doesnt mean its the best use of equipment.  Will they run the fate as airbus A380 or long Island RR  engines which were mothballed or the electric engines Amtrak retires based on the Acela.   It happens in the industry. Doubtful Metra will exercise the contract options

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, Railguy said:

Not intentionally.  Metra bought the wrong type of equipment for regional service including old frieght engines and the new cars on order.  Sure they ran in service doesnt mean its the best use of equipment.  Will they run the fate as airbus A380 or long Island RR  engines which were mothballed or the electric engines Amtrak retires based on the Acela.   It happens in the industry. Doubtful Metra will exercise the contract options

On what authority are you making these assertions? The general search indicates there are several now in revenue service.

Yours just seems the usual response here that EVERYTHING is junk until it has run for 20 years.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My comments have nothing to do with age of equipment , even if these SD70s' were delivered fresh off the assembly line.

These engines are for long express trains with limited stops.  Not condusive to multiple stop reggional network.  I would speculate Metra placed order pre pandemic based on serving the downtown rush commute.  Then the bottom fell out.

Of course Metra will spin this on positive light and make the best of it.  Sure they will be in service, they are rebuilt engines and are an asset to use.

For regional rail they need a new train  consist for the higher frequency segments and not  current locomotive hauled cars.  These can remaim in tje longer rush express markets.   Im basing this on looking at the ideas from midwest high speed rail association, CMAP PART section on regional rail and Metra strategic plan

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

19 hours ago, Railguy said:

Not intentionally.  Metra bought the wrong type of equipment for regional service including old frieght engines and the new cars on order.  Sure they ran in service doesnt mean its the best use of equipment.  Will they run the fate as airbus A380 or long Island RR  engines which were mothballed or the electric engines Amtrak retires based on the Acela.   It happens in the industry. Doubtful Metra will exercise the contract options

I'm not an expert per se, but I think your analysis is off.  Yes, engines are built for ling distance use, but they aren't LIMITED to that use.  Here's an analogy.   MCI  Prevost,  VanHool build buses and they get engines that can handle ling distance touring and travel and intercity runs.  But most operators who purchase them use those buses for lune runs. Commuter services, local charters, etc .  That's not a misuse if the equipment.   Similarly, using engines or locomotives from Amtrak or freight railroads to run Metra service is not misuse of equipment.   In fact, I believe its the BEST USE for the equipment.   As this type of equipment ages it's best to restrict the range to better maintain the equipment.   If you go back to my bus analogy,  charter companies and even Greyhound runs the newest equipment across the country,  but keeps its oldest equipment local or regional. 

Your Airbus 380 analogy was off because that's a niche plane that works well for certain carriers.  Even the carriers that had decided to retire them are bringing them back because they fill a need.   

The point is that using this refurbished equipment is financially affordable,  efficient,  and reliable until Metra can splurge on new locomotives. 

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, Railguy said:

My comments have nothing to do with age of equipment , even if these SD70s' were delivered fresh off the assembly line.

These engines are for long express trains with limited stops.  Not condusive to multiple stop reggional network.  I would speculate Metra placed order pre pandemic based on serving the downtown rush commute.  Then the bottom fell out.

Of course Metra will spin this on positive light and make the best of it.  Sure they will be in service, they are rebuilt engines and are an asset to use.

For regional rail they need a new train  consist for the higher frequency segments and not  current locomotive hauled cars.  These can remaim in tje longer rush express markets.   Im basing this on looking at the ideas from midwest high speed rail association, CMAP PART section on regional rail and Metra strategic plan

 

 

I agree with @artthouwill, but for different reasons.

PART is a joke, in the sense of equipment deployment, because Metra is never going to be able to afford to build yards for smaller coaches where the diesel lines now short turn trains: UPN: Highland Park or Winnetka; MD-N Lake Forest (formerly Deerfield), UP-NW Des Plaines, BNSF Fairview Ave. or Brookfield. It also seems ill-conceived that there would be more traffic between, say, Fox Lake and Lake-Cook, when the latter office corridor is much more decimated than the Loop. Hence, if there is any need for smaller coaches, it would be on the outer ends  of the system.  Since the MACHs appear operational on routes such as MD-N (unless a whole bunch of YouTubers have conspired to doctor the videos), that seems good enough. They just better not sound their horns outside my window.

Metra is acknowledging regional rail by:

  • the Feb. 2024 fare system.
  • The proposal for battery trainsets for the RI, which is about the only diesel line that has characteristics that may conform to the pattern.

Besides that, you seem to be arguing all over the place for a futile cause, from that they should be used only for excursions on a track that won't be in serviceable condition until 2028, to saying they are/were freight locomotives, to comparing them to doomed aircraft, to this PART fallacy. If you are saying they are not going to last as long a the 35-45 year old F40s, I don't think diesel power is going to last much more than another 15 years, anyway.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 10/31/2023 at 4:55 PM, Railguy said:

On a positive note they do look really cool!  How useful a 3 axle truck locomotives are  in commuter service remains to be seen.    It's wait and see time.

While they are six axle, only four are powered. Both end axles are idlers (1B-B1). More dictated by available cores than anything else. 4 axle cores are getting hard to come by.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...
  • 6 months later...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...